« Wall Street's Blues: The Perils of Right Wing Ideology | Main | Victory for Fairness and Opportunity in California »

Marriage: Calif. Constitution Should Stand for Our Best Hopes

This November, the people of California will be asked to vote on a question of equality, fairness - and love. For the first time, California's gay and lesbian couples are able to celebrate their lives together on equal terms under state law by entering into the civil institution of marriage.

An initiative on the November ballot seeks to change the California Constitution and take from them that opportunity. Californians should say "no" to the proposed amendment and ensure that our Constitution continues to stand for our best hopes and our highest aspirations.

A constitution is the founding document of a community. It is the statement of principle that protects the ability of all people in that community to live their lives and pursue their dreams. The same constitution that protects the right of churches and religions to decide when to recognize marriage as a sacrament - and the right of every citizen to express their opinions about the issue - also protects the right of gay and lesbian people to be treated equally under state law. That is what the California Supreme Court said last month, and the court was right.

This epic battle has personal relevance for me. In 1970, I fell in love with Gary Paterson, who is white, at the height of the Black Power movement.

Our love antagonized both black and white people.

The Supreme Court had struck down laws prohibiting interracial marriage just three years before in the landmark case, Loving vs. Virginia.

When we decided to marry, Gary's parents were so appalled that first we eloped to Hawaii and then settled in Oakland.

Gary did not speak to his parents for almost seven years. We had epithets yelled at us in public.

What gay men and lesbians are experiencing now as they seek to marry feels very familiar to me. The state has no right to tell anyone who they can or cannot love or marry. That is why this ballot initiative is misguided and cruel.

There are good people who continue to hold different beliefs about marriage for gay and lesbian couples. But amending our state Constitution is different. Writing a statement of inequality into the founding document of our state affects everyone's status in our community. It would say to some Californians that they are second-class citizens. We have gone down that road before, and we know where it leads.

That is why Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and U.S. Sen. Barack Obama have both clearly stated their opposition to the proposed California constitutional amendment, even though they do not personally support marriage for gay and lesbian couples. they are opposed because a constitution is different. If a European-American Republican governor and an African-American Democratic presidential candidate can agree on that principle, then I believe the people of California can rally around it as well.

Committed, loving gay and lesbian couples will begin legally marrying next week. Do not take their marriages away from them in November.

We are stronger as a community when we come together to strengthen all of our relationships. Divided, we are weaker.

Our state Constitution has a long history of reflecting the best of California, and bringing out the best in its people, guided by principles of fairness and equality. By rejecting this amendment in November, we protect what is best about our Constitution by ensuring that marriage - and the rights and responsibilities it entails - remains available to all couples.

The San Francisco Chronicle published this opinion piece on Friday, June 13, 2008.

Posted on Monday, June 16, 2008 at 11:40PM by Registered CommenterEJS | Comments3 Comments

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (3)

I am tired of the phrase "Committed, loving gay and lesbian couples" used in the context of the right to marry. If the gay or lesbian couples are irrational and self-absorbed, they have just as much right to marry as the rest of us.
June 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterDorothy Cornell
I'll never tire of the phrase "Committed, loving gay and lesbian couples." I'm thrilled to be witness to this historic time when the right to marry can be enjoyed by _all_ couples!
June 17, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterKeith Kamisugi
Thank you Eva for this piece - I was reminded of it when I attended the marrage celebration for my law partner and his partner of 11+ years last Saturday night. The room was filled with love and elation that finally we have reached an equal status for gay and lesbian couples...let's hope we don't lose all in the fall.
August 12, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterChristine Brigagliano

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.